Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
International approaches and Russian methods for assessing internal control systems were analyzed. It is proposed to consider the effectiveness of this system from an internal and external point of view. The external effectiveness of the internal control system involves the integration of risk management into decision-making at all levels of company management aimed at ensuring the medium and long-term efficiency of the corporation It is assumed that the necessary conditions for effectiveness are the passage of risk management and control through all decision-making processes, as well as the involvement of employees in this process. In this paper, using the example of the compliance service, an analysis of the effects of its activities is conducted, statistical data of the applied performance indicators of this service are analyzed, as well as the indicators for assessing the internal audit service in Russian companies. Based on the analysis of existing methods, a model for assessing the riskoriented internal control system “COSO – three lines of defense” is proposed, representing a matrix, the elements of which are key performance indicators that assess the contribution and involvement of employees and departments in the implementation of each element of the COSO model, as well as the areas within which it is possible to develop such indicators.
risk-oriented internal control system, evaluation of the effectiveness of the internal control system
1. Azhimov O. Zaklyuchenie vnutrennego audita publichnogo obschestva dlya godovogo obschego sobraniya akcionerov // Akcionernoe obschestvo: voprosy korporativnogo upravleniya 2021. №6. S.1216.
2. Brusencova M.L. Neformal'nyy podhod k risk menedzhmentu v korporativnom upravlenii (nonformal) // Akcionernoe obschestvo: voprosy korporativnogo upravleniya 2020. №4. S. 5258.
3. Vnedrenie komplaensa snizhaet kolichestvo narusheniy i rashody na shtrafy URL: https://ac.gov.ru/news/page/ vnedrenie komplaensa snizaet kolicestvo narusenij i rashodynastrafy26839 (data obrascheniya 15.10.2024).
4. Velizhanskaya T. Sluzhba vnutrennego audita: proverki effektivnosti processov // Akcionernoe obschestvo: voprosy korporativnogo upravleniya 2021. №2. S. 2230.
5. Gritans Ya.M. Sistema vnutrennego kontrolya: kak effektivno borot'sya s korporativnym moshennichestvom / Gritans Ya.M. – M.: Infortropik Media, 2011. – 304 s.
6. Dannye issledovaniya OOO «SOLAR SEK'YuRITI» «Moshennichestvo i sliv dannyh v rossiyskih organizaciyah» URL: https://rtsolar.ru/upload/iblock/9e4/wbe0s6mkqyd09ym ydi3l80pv688yhfml/RTK_Solar_issledovanieMoshennichestvoislivydannykhvrossyskikhkompaniyakh. pdf? ysclid=lpxs2wxhqq594157069 (data obrascheniya 15.07.2025)
7. Issledovanie tekuschego sostoyaniya i tendenciy razvitiya vnutrennego audita finansovyh organizaciy v Rossii // Akcionernoe obschestvo: voprosy korporativnogo upravleniya 2021. №6. S. 3747.
8. Informacionnoe pis'mo Banka Rossii ot 01.10.2020 N IN0628/143 «O rekomendaciyah po organizacii upravleniya riskami, vnutrennego kontrolya, vnutrennego audita, raboty komiteta soveta direktorov (nablyudatel'nogo soveta) po auditu v publichnyh akcionernyh obsches tvah» // ht tps://www.cbr.ru/StaticHtml/ File/59420/20201001_in_06_28143.pdf
9. Zverev E.B. Ocenka deyatel'nosti vnutrennego audita: primenenie prakticheskogo rukovodstva Institute of Internal Auditors // Akcionernoe obschestvo: voprosy korporativnogo upravleniya 2018. – №7. S.4250.
10. Zueva I.A. Postroenie modeli i razvitie instrumentov vnutrennego kontrolya v sovremennoy sisteme upravleniya predpriyatiem // Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta imeni S.Yu. Vitte. Seriya 1. Ekonomika i upravlenie. 2023. № 3. (46) S.101111. DOI: https://doi.org/10.21777/2587-554X-2023-3-101-113; EDN: https://elibrary.ru/PWNSXG
11. Kostina O.V., Dvoeglazov D.E. Analiz sostoyaniya sistemy vnutrennego kontrolya i audita na primere PAO «NK «ROSNEFT'» // Nauchno prakticheskiy elektronnyy zhurnal «Original'nye issledovaniya» (ORIS). 2023. №10. S.194204.
12. Komplaens v cifrah URL: https://compliance.su/info/ articles/komplaensvtsifrakh/ (data obrascheniya 14.10.2024)
13. Masyuk N.A. Sistema KPE dlya podrazdeleniya vnutrennego audita predpriyatiy s organizovannoy sistemoy korporativnogo upravleniya // Akcionernoe obschestvo: voprosy korporativnogo upravleniya 2020. №10. S.3440.
14. Nezavisimost' sluzhby vnutrennego audita ot menedzhmenta organizacii // Akcionernoe obschestvo: voprosy korporativnogo upravleniya 2024. №4. S.4653
15. Parfenov A. Kak sozdat' sistemu upravleniya riskami, effektivnuyu na vseh urovnyah upravleniya // Akcionernoe obschestvo: voprosy korporativnogo upravleniya 2024. №11. S. 3339.
16. Portret sovremennogo komplaensspecialista URL: https://kept.ru/news/portret sovremennogo komplaens spetsialista/?utm_source=google.com&utm_ medium=organic&utm_campaign=google.com&utm_ referrer=google.com (data obrascheniya 20.10.2024)
17. Measuring Internal audit effectiveness and efficiency // https://www.theiia.org/globalassets/documents/content/ articles/guidance/practiceguides/measuringinternalauditeffectiveness and efficiency/practice guide measuring internalauditeffectiveness.pdf?ref=clarissalucas.com
