Moscow State University. M.V. Lomonosov (Department of Socio-Cultural Design and Development of Territories, Professor)
Moskva, Moscow, Russian Federation
e relevance of the presented research is determined by the fact that in order to implement the overdue transformation of the national economy, it is important not only to study the previous experience of such transformations, including, of course, Gaidar’s reforms, but also to overcome the continuing negative impact of the latter. The purpose of the presented research is a comprehensive analysis of the negative consequences of Gaidar’s reforms for the national economy in the interests of finding effective ways to overcome them. The scientific novelty of the results obtained lies in the identification of a complex of negative consequences of Gaidar’s reforms for the national economy, including: predatory redistribution of property, price liberalization, haste in implementing reforms, falling investment in fixed assets, liberalization of foreign trade, increased crime and corruption, collapse of the military-industrial complex , falling living standards of the population, rising inflation and budget deficits, the launch of a mechanism for the emission of bureaucrats, the formation of a colonial model of the national economy, the implementation of a model of state-quasi-monopoly capitalism. The practical significance of the results obtained lies in the possibility of their use in overcoming the negative consequences of the implementation of Gaidar’s reforms when carrying out the transformation of the national economy in modern conditions.
methodological analysis, management, development and implementation, Gaidar reforms, part 4, results
1. «Privatizaciya byla troynym obmanom»: kak vauchery stali krahom nadezhd novoy Rossii. https://www.kp.ru/daily/27451/4655210/ (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
2. A. Chubays: Privatizaciya voobsche ne byla ekonomicheskim processom. Ona reshala glavnuyu zadachu — ostanovit' kommunizm. https://topwar.ru/19976-a.chubaysprivatizaciya-voobsche-ne-byla-ekonomicheskim-processom.-ona-reshala-glavnuyuzadachu-ostanovit-kommunizm.html (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
3. Bezborodov A., Eliseeva N., Shestakov V. Perestroyka i krah SSSR. 1985—1993. SPb. Norma, 2010. – 216 s.
4. Borisov E.F. Ekonomicheskaya teoriya: Uchebnik. — 3-e izd., pererab. i dop. — M.: Yurayt-Izdat, 2005. — 399 s.
5. Valovoy vnutrenniy produkt. Nacional'nye scheta. Oficial'naya statistika. https://web.archive.org/web/20130603204831/http://www.gks.ru/wps/wcm/connect/ro sstat_main/rosstat/ru/statistics/accounts/# (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
6. Gaydar E.T. Vlast' i sobstvennost'. — SPb.: Norma, 2009. – 331 s.
7. Genprokuratura postavila rekord po delam o peresmotre privatizacii 90-h. Chto obschego u predpriyatiy, kotorye izymaet gosudarstvo. https://rtvi.com/stories/genprokuratura-postavila-rekord-po-delam-o-peresmotreprivatizaczii-90-h-chto-obshhego-u-predpriyatij-kotorye-izymaet-gosudarstvo/ (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
8. Gerasimov G. I. «Istoriya sovremennoy Rossii: poisk i obretenie svobody (1985—2008)», s. 89-91.
9. Glaz'ev S.Yu. O neotlozhnyh merah po ukrepleniyu ekonomicheskoy bezopasnosti Rossii i vyvodu rossiyskoy ekonomiki na traektoriyu operezhayuschego razvitiya. Doklad / S.Yu. Glaz'ev. M.: Institut ekonomicheskih strategiy, Russkiy biograficheskiy institut, 2015. — 60 s.
10. Gosudarstvennyy doklad “O sostoyanii zdorov'ya naseleniya Rossiyskoy Federacii v 1992 godu”. Ministerstvo zdravoohraneniya RF i Rossiyskaya Akademiya medicinskih nauk. Moskva, 1993.
11. Delyagin M. Reformy Gaydara nanesli Rossii vred, sopostavimyy s nashestviem Gitlera. https://izborsk-club.ru/6292 (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
12. Efim Smulyanskiy: Reformy Gaydara. Okonchanie. https://club.berkovichzametki.com/?p=53772 (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
13. Ivanov E. 30 let gaydarovskih reform: strana proigrala reformatoram. https://www.nakanune.ru/articles/118179/ (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
14. Illarionov A. Slovo i delo. // «Kontinent» 2007, №134. https://web.archive.org/web/20110614125742/http://magazines.russ.ru/continent/2007 /134/il7-pr.html (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
15. Indeksy potrebitel'skih cen na tovary i uslugi naseleniyu po Rossiyskoy Federacii v 1991-2009gg. na konec perioda, v %. https://web.archive.org/web/20100227203140/http://www.gks.ru/free_doc/new_site/pr ices/potr/2009/I-ipc.htm (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
16. Kak razvorovali Rossiyu: 7 samyh gromkih privatizaciy 90h. https://dzen.ru/a/X9m3x-eukz4ec-aA (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
17. Karpov M. Egor sdelal svoe delo. Kak pravitel'stvo El'cina-Gaydara provodilo ekonomicheskie reformy v 1992 godu. https://lenta.ru/articles/2016/08/23/gaidar/ (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
18. Lopatnikov L.I. Pereval. K 15-letiyu rynochnyh reform v Rossii. — M.-SPB.: Norma, 2006. - 388 s.
19. Maykl Intriligeytor. Shokiruyuschiy proval "shokovoy terapii" https://web.archive.org/web/20110716070226/http://rusref.nm.ru/intr.htm# (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
20. MVF - Rossii: A nam vasha ekonomicheskaya politika nravitsya! https://finance.rambler.ru/economics/50130019/?utm_content=finance_media&utm_m edium=read_more&utm_source=copylink (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
21. Minaev B. Gaydar glazami russkoy istorii. http://www.vestnikevropy.ru/issues/gaydar-glazami-russkoy-istorii.html (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
22. Nauchno-obrazovatel'nyy portal IQ – Nacional'nyy issledovatel'skiy universitet «Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki». https://iq.hse.ru (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
23. Nechaev A. Rossiya na perelome. — M.: Astrel', 2010. - 575 s.
24. Nechaev A.A. Sokraschenie voennoy nagruzki na byudzhet. Istoriya novoy Rossii. http://ru-90.ru/node/1226 (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
25. Nikolay Petrakov: «V Skolkovo priedut ili sharlatany, ili amerikanskie shpiony». https://www.business-gazeta.ru/article/32844 (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
26. Obnischanie «narodnyh mass» Rossii. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Obnischanie- «narodnyh-mass»-RossiiSycheva/b460a04d0a535e290fd0bba7ce6c30a6f0e33751 (data obrascheniya23.01.2024)
27. PARADOKSY ROSSIYSKOY DEMILITARIZACII. // Voennyy VESTNIK № 1, MEZhREGIONYI FOND INFORMACIONNYH TEHNOLOGII. Moskva, Aprel' 1998. https://svop.ru/wpcontent/uploads/2018/10/VoennyVestnikMFIT_No1_PARADOXY-ROSSIISKOIDEMILITARIZACII.pdf (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
28. Petr Aven, Al'fred Koh. Revolyuciya Gaydara: Istoriya reform 90-h iz pervyh ruk. — M.: Al'pina Pablisher, 2013. — 472 s.
29. Polterovich V.M. Strategii institucional'nyh reform, ili Iskusstvo reform: Preprint WP10/2007/08. — M.: GU VShE, 2007. — 24 c.
30. Priymak A., Vasil'ev N., Moshkin M. Kak Gaydar pridumal dlya Rossii «shokovuyu terapiyu». https://vz.ru/economy/2022/1/2/1134806.html (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
31. Putin vysoko ocenil vazhnost' operezhayuschego razvitiya obrabatyvayuschey promyshlennosti. https://iz.ru/1493350/2023-04-04/putin-vysoko-otcenil-vazhnostoperezhaiushchego-razvitiia-obrabatyvaiushchei-promyshlennosti (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
32. Putin zayavil, chto Rossiya stalkivaetsya s ser'eznymi vyzovami. https://tass.ru/politika/20226477?ysclid=ltr13iqmgh103862229 (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
33. Putin rasskazal o sotrudnikah CRU v rossiyskom pravitel'stve v 1990-e. https://www.rbc.ru/politics/10/12/2021/61b2769b9a7947748667a9ce (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
34. Razdel 2 Proizvodstvo i potreblenie produktov pitaniya v RF. http://www.karamurza.ru/books/wb/wb007.html (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
35. Real'nye raspolagaemye denezhnye dohody v % k predyduschemu godu. // Rosstat. https://rosstat.gov.ru/folder/13397 (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
36. Rimashevskaya N. M. Chelovek i reformy: Sekrety vyzhivaniya. — M.: ISEPN RAN, 2003. — 392 s.
37. Simonyan R.H. Reformy v Rossii 1990-h godov: ob argumentah «za» // Sociologicheskie issledovaniya, 2006, № 6. S. 114—122.
38. Sudy nachali massovo otmenyat' nezakonnuyu privatizaciyu i vozvraschayut strane predpriyatiya. https://sibkray.ru/news/2127/974860/ (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
39. Tebekin A.V. METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ MENEDZhMENTA RAZRABOTKI I REALIZACII GAYDAROVSKIH REFORM. ChAST' 1: VZAIMOSVYaZ' VNUTRENNEGO I VNEShNEGO MENEDZhMENTA. // Zhurnal ekonomicheskih issledovaniy. 2023. T. 9. № 5. S. 3-17.
40. Tebekin A.V. Metodologicheskiy analiz menedzhmenta razrabotki i realizacii gaydarovskih reform (chast' 2: tendencii razvitiya gaydarovskih reform vnutrennim menedzhmentom v 1990-e, 2000-e i 2010-e gody). // Zhurnal ekonomicheskih issledovaniy. 2023. T. 9. № 6, s.3-24.
41. Tebekin A.V. METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ MENEDZhMENTA RAZRABOTKI I REALIZACII GAYDAROVSKIH REFORM (ChAST' 3: ANALIZ ORGANIZACII DEYaTEL'NOSTI I KADROVOGO SOSTAVA VNUTRENNEGO TOP-MENEDZhMENTA). // Zhurnal ekonomicheskih issledovaniy. 2024. T. 10. № 1. S. 3-16.
42. Tebekin A.V. TEORETIKO-METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ EKONOMIChESKIH REFORM E. GAYDARA (ChAST' 1: PREDPOSYLKI REALIZACII). // Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Ekonomika i upravlenie. 2022. № 3 (59). S. 237-249.
43. Tebekin A.V. TEORETIKO METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ EKONOMIChESKIH REFORM E. GAYDARA (ChAST' 2: ANALIZ SODERZhANIYa BLOKA REFORM "PREODOLENIE UGROZY GOLODA I TOTAL'NOGO DEFICITA TOVAROV"). // Epomen. Global. 2022. № 29. S. 39-56.
44. Tebekin A.V. TEORETIKO-METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ EKONOMIChESKIH REFORM E. GAYDARA (ChAST' 3: ANALIZ SODERZhANIYa BLOKA REFORM «NORMALIZACII FINANSOV I PODAVLENIE INFLYaCII»). // Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Ekonomika i upravlenie. 2022. № 4 (60). S. 229-247.
45. Tebekin A.V. TEORETIKO-METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ EKONOMIChESKIH REFORM E. GAYDARA (ChAST' 4: ANALIZ BLOKA REFORM "STRUKTURNAYa PERESTROYKA EKONOMIKI"). // Zhurnal ekonomicheskih issledovaniy. 2022. T. 8. № 4. S. 3-16.
46. Tebekin A.V., Tihonova I.V. TEORETIKO-METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ EKONOMIChESKIH REFORM E. GAYDARA (ChAST' 5: ANALIZ BLOKA REFORM «SOZDANIE OSNOV RYNOChNOGO HOZYaYSTVA»). // Zhurnal issledovaniy po upravleniyu. 2022. T. 8. № 5. S. 23-40.
47. Tebekin A.V. TEORETIKO-METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ EKONOMIChESKIH REFORM E. GAYDARA (ChAST' 6.1: ANALIZ BLOKA REFORM "SOZDANIE I RAZVITIE ROSSIYSKIH GOSUDARSTVENNYH INSTITUTOV I MEZhDUNARODNYE DELA"). // Zhurnal ekonomicheskih issledovaniy. 2022. T. 8. № 6. S. 3-16.
48. Tebekin A.V. TEORETIKO-METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ EKONOMIChESKIH REFORM E. GAYDARA (ChAST' 6.2: ANALIZ BLOKA REFORM «SOZDANIE I RAZVITIE ROSSIYSKIH GOSUDARSTVENNYH INSTITUTOV I MEZhDUNARODNYE DELA»). // Zhurnal ekonomicheskih issledovaniy. 2023. T. 9. № 3. S. 3-19.
49. Tebekin A.V. TEORETIKO-METODOLOGIChESKIY ANALIZ EKONOMIChESKIH REFORM E. GAYDARA (ChAST' 6.3: OCENKA REZUL'TATOV PROVEDENIYa ADMINISTRATIVNOY REFORMY). // Zhurnal ekonomicheskih issledovaniy. 2023. T. 9. № 4. S. 3-23.
50. Tebekin, A.V. Geopolitekonomicheskiy aspekt issledovaniya prodvizheniya k novomu kachestvu tehnologiy, ekonomiki i obschestva. // Vestnik TvGU. Seriya: Ekonomika i upravlenie. 2021, №3, S. 38-54.
51. Travin D. Ya. Ocherki noveyshey istorii Rossii. Kniga pervaya: 1985—1999. SPb. Norma, 2010. – 365 s.
52. Urinson Ya. SNOVA DUET VETER PEREMEN. EKONOMIChESKIE REFORMY V ROSSII — 20 LET SPUSTYa. Https://www.vestnikevropy.ru/upload/iblock/dd1/dd10bc2996a617f942a2807ff3b56bdf.pdf (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
53. Fedorin V. Chestnyy chelovek beret vlast', tol'ko kogda vse ploho. https://www.forbes.ru/interview/35045-chestnyi-chelovek-beret-vlast-tolko-kogdavse-ploho (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
54. Hlebnikov P. Gaydarovskie reformy. // Krestnyy otec Kremlya Boris Berezovskiy, ili istoriya razgrableniya Rossii. https://biography.wikireading.ru/63639 (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
55. Chernomyrdin V. S. Narodnyy prem'er. 1990—1998: memuary. — M.: ANO «Muzey V. S. Chernomyrdina», 2013. — 496 s.
56. Ekonomist Maslennikov: Rossii neobhodima strukturnaya transformaciya ekonomiki. https://dzen.ru/a/Y0_AdjlIrBZYGWl6 (data obrascheniya 23.01.2024)
57. Yasin E. G. Rossiyskaya ekonomika: istoki i panorama rynochnyh reform. Kurs lekciy. — M.: GU VShE, 2002. – 435 s.
