graduate student
In the municipality of Tula, there is no phased and systematic audit, as well as internal (by the Tula City administration) and external (by the Control and Accounting Chamber of the Ministry of Defense of Tula) audit of the implementation of municipal programs. This audit should be carried out to assess the achievement of the goals, objectives, indicators of the municipal program, activities to achieve the results of its implementation, the ratio of results with the resources spent to ensure the effective use of municipal budget funds.
municipal program, urban planning, program implementation indicator, effectiveness, efficiency, resource provision, audit
1. On the approval of the municipal program of the municipality of Tula "Development of urban development activities on the territory of the municipality of Tula": Resolution of the administration of Tula dated 12.12.2019 No. 4424 URL: https://npatula-city.ru/upload/iblock/450/158%20ot%2030.03.2023%20-%20NPA.pdf. (in Russian)
2. Methodological guidelines for the development, implementation and evaluation of the effectiveness and efficiency of the implementation of municipal programs of the municipality of Tula: Order of the Financial Department of the Tula City Administration dated 12/30/2021 No. 79. URL: https://www.tula.ru/activity/economics/mp/mp1/index.php. (in Russian)
3. Information on the results of monitoring and evaluation of the effectiveness of the implementation of municipal programs of the municipality of Tula. URL: https://www.tula.ru/activity/economics/mp/monitoring/ (in Russian).
4. Zakharchuk, S.D. Approaches to determining the effectiveness of the implementation of municipal programs / S.D. Zakharchuk, A.V. Kostyukov // Education and Law. 2022. № 5. URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/podhody-k-opredeleniyu-effektivnosti-realizatsii-munitsipalnyh-programm (in Russian).
5. Kuznetsov, M. E. Evaluation of the effectiveness and efficiency of municipal programs and departmental target programs / M. E. Kuznetsov, I. P. Marchenko // Siberian International. - 2017. - No. 19. - pp. 130-132. - EDN ZHHCML (in Russian).
6. Yarullin, R. R. Evaluation of the effectiveness of the implementation of municipal programs / R. R. Yarullin, A. P. Manaicheva // International Journal of Humanities and Natural Sciences. 2018. №12-2. URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/otsenka-effektivnosti-realizatsii-munitsipalnyh-programm (in Russian).
7. Chen, Y.-T.; Yang, Y.-Y.; Chen, Y.-H. Assessing the COVID-19 Impact of Projects under Construction with Monte Carlo Simulation. Architecture 2023, 3, 175-194. https://doi.org/10.3390/architecture3020011
