The article is devoted to economic analysis’ conceptual framework in the tax law. The author examines modern aspects of the correlation between Law and Economics, the content of the principle of the economic basis for tax, expresses her opinion on the matter of the possibility to verify the economic feasibility of taxes and fees in the context of constitutional proceedings. Special attention is attributed to the issues of application of economic analysis’ methodological tools in tax law. In 2012, while considering tax disputes arbitration courts focused on the application of economic analysis. Based on the analysis of law enforcement practice, the author identifies problematic issues in the use of economic analysis in the tax law interpretation, defines the scope of economic analysis and its specific features. The article introduces concepts of “economic and legal impact area” and “economic and legal impact coverage area”, identifies their characteristics and specific features of a regulatory nature.
Economic analysis, tax law, economics, efficiency, tax disputes.
1. Braun D. The Discrepancy Between “Ideal” and “Real World” International Tax Rules - What Drives Politicians When Making the Rules?. WU International Taxation Research Paper Series. 2012. No. 10.
2. Crespo C. A. The “Ability to Pay” as a Fundamental Right: Rethinking the Foundations of Tax Law. Mexican Law Review. 2009. Vol. III. No. 1.
3. James S., Edwards A. Importance of Behavioral Economics in Tax Research and Tax Reform: The Issues of Tax Compliance and Tax Simplification. University of Exeter, 2007. Paper number 07/14.
4. Kraft G., Krengel R. Economic Analysis of Tax Law: Current and Past Research Investigated. Wittenberg, 2003.
5. Raskolnikov A. Accepting the Limits of Tax Law and Economics, 98 Cornell L. REV. 523, 573-80. Shaviro D. The Economics of Tax Law. New York University Public Law and Legal Theory Working Papers. Paper 455. 2014. No. 3.
6. Avdiyskiy V. I. Ekonomicheskiy analiz prava: sravnitel´no-pravovoe issledovanie. Mezhdunarodnoe publichnoe i chastnoe pravo. 2012. № 3.
7. Antonov M. V. O nekotorykh teoreticheskikh problemakh primeneniya ekonomicheskogo analiza prava v Rossii. Pravo. 2011. № 3.
8. Baranov V. D. Ekonomicheskaya bezopasnost´ vneshnetorgovoy sfery Rossii v usloviyakh globalizatsii ekonomiki (teoretiko-metodologicheskiy podkhod): avtoref. dis.... d-ra ekon. nauk. M., 2011.
9. Baranov N. S., Pavlova L. P. Nalogovyy rezhim dlya shel´fovykh mestorozhdeniy. Finansy. 2014. № 4.
10. Bar´er F. i dr. Tsivilisticheskie pravovye traditsii pod voprosom (po povodu dokladov Doing Business Vsemirnogo banka) / per. s fr. A. Gryadova. M., 2007.
11. Blankenagel´ A. Konstitutsionnoe ponimanie i funktsii ekonomicheskoy obosnovannosti nalogov s tochki zreniya spetsialista iz Germanii. Sravnitel´noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2009. № 5.
12. Bratus´ S. N. O roli sovetskogo prava v ispol´zovanii ekonomicheskikh zakonov sotsializma. O roli prava v ispol´zovanii ob´´ektivnykh ekonomicheskikh zakonov / pod red. S. N. Bratusya. M., 1954.
13. Bratus´ S. N. Sootnoshenie ekonomicheskikh i administrativno-pravovykh metodov upravleniya sotsialisticheskim proizvodstvom. M., 1965.
14. Busse R. Ekonomicheskoe istolkovanie norm nalogovogo prava i ekonomicheskoy obosnovannosti v nalogooblozhenii. Nalogovye spory: opyt Rossii i drugikh stran: po mater. VII Mezhdunar. nauch.- prakt. konf. 18 oktyabrya 2013 g. / pod red. S. G. Pepelyaeva. M., 2014.
15. Bedan Sh. Pravo litsa i gosudarstvo. Voronezh, 1917.
16. Vlasenko N. A. Pravoponimanie v svete kategoriy opredelennosti i neopredelennosti. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2014. № 2.
17. Vorozhikhin V. V. Ob opredelenii ekonomicheskoy bezopasnosti v usloviyakh globalizatsii. Bezopasnost´ biznesa. 2014. № 3.
18. Gadzhiev G. A. Predmet konstitutsionnoy ekonomiki. Ocherki konstitutsionnoy ekonomiki. 23 oktyabrya 2009 g. / pod red. G. A. Gadzhieva. M., 2009.
19. Gadzhiev G. A. Ekonomicheskaya effektivnost´, pravovaya etika i doverie k gosudarstvu. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2012. № 1.
20. Grekova I. Yu. FATCA: novye trudnosti kontrolya. Vnutrenniy kontrol´ v kreditnoy organizatsii. 2012. № 3.
21. Grekhenig K., Gelter M. Transatlanticheskie razlichiya v pravovoy mysli: amerikanskiy ekonomicheskiy analiz prava protiv nemetskogo doktrinalizma. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava. 2010. № 6.
22. Zapol´skiy S. V. Ekonomiko-pravovye instituty regulirovaniya regional´nogo razvitiya. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2014. № 4.
23. Zor´kin V. D. Pravovoe regulirovanie ekonomiki: global´nye tendentsii i rossiyskiy opyt. URL: http://www.rg.ru/printable/2012/06/01/regulirovanie.html (data obrashcheniya: 01.08.2014).
24. Ivlieva M. F. Finansovoe pravo kak nauka i uchebnaya distsiplina v Moskovskom gosudarstvennom universitete. Finansovoe pravo. 2010. № 2.
25. Kazantsev N. M. Metod finansovogo prava: genezis. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2012. № 9.
26. Kurbatov A. Ya. Zashchita prav i zakonnykh interesov v usloviyakh «modernizatsii» pravovoy sistemy Rossii. M., 2013.
27. Kucherov I. I. Teoriya nalogov i sborov. M., 2009.
28. Lafitskiy V. I. Obespechenie ekonomicheskogo razvitiya kak funktsiya prava. Verkhovenstvo prava kak faktor ekonomiki: mezhdunarodnaya kollektivnaya monografiya. M., 2013.
29. Mazaev V. D. Perspektivnye napravleniya mezhdistsiplinarnogo analiza vzaimodeystviya konstitutsionno-pravovykh i ekonomicheskikh institutov. Instituty konstitutsionnogo prava / otv. red. L. V. Andrichenko, A. E. Postnikov. M., 2013.
30. Nefedov D. V. Ekonomicheskaya teoriya kak osnovanie konstitutsionnogo tolkovaniya. Pravovedenie. 2013. № 5.
31. Neformal´nyy podkhod. Rossiyskaya gazeta. 2012. 11 dek.
32. Odintsova M. I. Ekonomicheskie dovody v Konstitutsionnom Sude: vozmozhnosti i granitsy ikh primeneniya. Ocherki konstitutsionnoy ekonomiki. 23 oktyabrya 2009 g. / pod red. G. A. Gadzhieva. M., 2009.
33. Stepanov D. I. Voprosy metodologii tsivilisticheskoy doktriny. Aktual´nye problemy grazhdanskogo prava: sb. st. Vyp. 6. M., 2003.
34. Schetnaya palata vidit poteri v byudzhete-2014. RBC-daily. 2013. 11 noyab.
35. Syrunina T. Perspektivy i slozhnosti primeneniya sudami ekonomicheskogo analiza prava pri razreshenii sporov. Sravnitel´noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2011. № 4.
36. Tikhomirov Yu. A. Pravovoe prostranstvo i vyzovy globalizatsii. Pravovoe prostranstvo i chelovek: monografiya / otv. red. Yu. A. Tikhomirov, E. V. Pulyaeva, N. I. Khludeneva. M., 2012.
37. Trubetskoy E. Entsiklopediya prava. M., 1916.
38. Ulen T. Teoriya ratsional´nogo vybora v ekonomicheskom analize prava. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava. 2011. № 3.
39. Farber D. Otzhivshaya parodiya. Vozrozhdennyy pragmatizm: ironiya teoremy Kouza. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava. 2012. № 2.
40. Khabrieva T. Ya. Administrativnye protsedury i administrativnye bar´ery: v poiskakh optimal´noy modeli sootnosheniya. Administrativnye protsedury i kontrol´ v svete evropeyskogo opyta / pod red. T. Ya. Khabrievoy, Zh. Marku. M., 2011.
41. Khabrieva T. Ya. Ekonomiko-pravovoy analiz: metodologicheskiy podkhod. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2010. № 12.
42. Khavanova I. A. Fiskal´nyy (nalogovyy) suverenitet i ego granitsy v integratsionnykh obrazovaniyakh. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2013. № 11.
43. Khavanova I. A. Ekonomicheskoe osnovanie naloga, ili Homo economicus v nalogovom prave?. Nalogoved. 2013. № 9.
44. Khalfina R. O. O pravovoy forme ekonomicheskikh otnosheniy. Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo. 1965. № 7.
45. Shershenevich G. F. Sistema torgovykh deystviy. Kritika osnovnykh ponyatiy torgovogo prava. Kazan´, 1888.
46. Sheffer G.-B. Effektivnost´ kak pravovaya norma. Istoki. Vyp. 5: Ekonomika v kontekste istorii i kul´tury. M., 2004.
47. Shmakov A. V. Ekonomicheskiy analiz prava: ucheb. posobie. Ch. 1. Novosibirsk, 2005.
48. Ekonomika i pravo: novyy kontekst// Rossiyskaya gazeta. 2014. 21 maya.
49. Ekonomiko-pravovye instituty regulirovaniya regional´nogo razvitiya Rossiyskoy Federatsii: monografiya / pod red. N. M. Kazantseva. M., 2013.
50. Ekonomicheskiy podkhod k pravu: kriticheskoe vystuplenie Tsento Vel´yanovski. URL: http://www.nsu.ru/nif/people_1/016.pdf (data obrashcheniya: 20.11.2014).
